Making the Cut: The Debate Between Water and Oil for Sharpening Stones

Making the Cut_ The Debate Between Water and Oil for Sharpening Stones


For chefs, craftsmen, and anyone who uses a knife regularly, maintaining a sharp blade is key to efficiency and safety. One of the primary tools used to achieve this sharpness is a sharpening stone. However, using a sharpening stone is not as simple as running your knife across it. There's a crucial question to answer: Should you use water or oil on your sharpening stone? Let's delve into the depths of this query and provide you with the knowledge to make an informed decision.

The Role of Lubrication in Sharpening

Firstly, it's important to understand why we use a lubricant – water or oil – when sharpening a knife. The main purpose of using a lubricant is to reduce friction, preventing the stone and knife from overheating, which can affect the blade's temper and performance. Lubrication also helps float away metal and abrasive particles, known as swarf, which can clog the stone and inhibit its sharpening abilities.

Now, the question remains: water or oil?

Water Stones: The Case for Water

As the name suggests, water stones are designed to be used with water. These stones, both natural and synthetic varieties, are particularly popular in the culinary world due to their fast cutting action. They are also favored because water is readily available, easy to clean up, and does not leave a residue on the stone or blade.

Before using a water stone, it should be soaked in water until it's thoroughly saturated. The soaking time can vary from a few minutes to a few hours, depending on the stone. During the sharpening process, water is continually applied to the stone to keep it lubricated and to wash away swarf.

Oil Stones: The Case for Oil

Oil stones, including Arkansas stones and India stones, are traditionally lubricated with oil. The oil serves the same purpose as water – reducing friction and carrying away swarf. Oil has a higher viscosity than water, meaning it stays on the stone's surface longer and provides a consistent layer of lubrication.

The key advantage of oil is that it provides smoother sharpening action, and the stone does not need to be soaked before use – a few drops of oil just before and during sharpening are sufficient. However, once a stone has been used with oil, it cannot be used with water as the oil fills the stone's pores and repels water.

The oil used can be specially formulated sharpening oil or just mineral oil. However, oils with additives (such as cooking oils or automotive oils) should be avoided as they can leave a residue and potentially damage the stone or blade.

Which One Should You Choose?

The choice between water and oil largely comes down to the type of stone you have (water stone or oil stone) and personal preference. Both water and oil are effective lubricants for sharpening stones, and they each have their own pros and cons.

Water is easy to clean up, readily available, and works well with fast-cutting water stones. However, it evaporates quickly and may require frequent reapplication during long sharpening sessions. Water stones also need to be soaked before use and allowed to dry thoroughly after use to prevent cracking or warping.

Oil provides a smoother sharpening action and does not require the stone to be pre-soaked. The stone can also be stored oil-soaked and ready for use. However, oil can be messier than water, and it may leave a residue on the stone and blade. Once a stone is used with oil, it can't be used with water.


To decide whether to use water or oil on your sharpening stone, first consider the type of stone you have – water stone or oil stone. Then, consider your personal preferences and the specifics of your sharpening task. Do you need fast cutting action, or do you prefer a smoother, slower sharpening process? Do you mind the cleanup and maintenance associated with oil, or would you prefer the simplicity and cleanliness of water?

No matter which lubricant you choose, remember that the goal is to maintain a sharp and efficient blade. The art of sharpening is a skill worth mastering – it not only extends the life of your tools but also enhances your efficiency and safety, whether in the kitchen, workshop, or great outdoors. As with many things in life, practice and patience will yield the best results in your sharpening endeavors.

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published